logoalt Hacker News

intendedyesterday at 7:30 AM1 replyview on HN

Yes. In the end what mattered truly was the expression.

However - since we are humans - we also care about the artist.

Creating something without the effort previous works involved, can and do affect the context and understanding of it.

Hah - just thought of one good example: how would people feel about talking to only fans creators, if they didn’t know it was AI.


Replies

chiiyesterday at 7:41 AM

> Creating something without the effort previous works involved, can and do affect the context and understanding of it

not really. Unless you place value on _effort_, rather than be objectively outcome based. Someone digging a hole with a spoon doesn't make it a better hole than a jackhammer.

I maintain that the work itself - that is, the contents of what is being expressed - is the sole judgement of how good the works is. Not the authorship, LLM-usage or otherwise.

show 1 reply