logoalt Hacker News

FridayoLearytoday at 2:12 PM11 repliesview on HN

[flagged]


Replies

lm28469today at 2:40 PM

> It's not a declaration of war to project your military power to a region you have an interest in.

There was no declaration of war by anyone so far, and I doubt Iran would wait for an official letter telling them they're allowed to sink a US allied carrier, especially now that they killed the leader's wife, son, dad, and a bunch of relatives (plus the only dude who the US could reasonably negotiate with)

show 1 reply
rcxdudetoday at 2:17 PM

I think the international community is demonstrating to the US that they can't drop their military support for their allies and also expect that they still help to clean up their messes.

show 1 reply
marcosdumaytoday at 3:05 PM

NATO countries need to keep their military close to the Noth Atlantic to protect Greenland from recent unexpected threats.

georgefrownytoday at 2:37 PM

As the UK chief of defense staff commented drily: "we have an aircraft carrier, it's called Cyprus".

ceejayoztoday at 5:04 PM

> Unrelated but the UK has 2 aircraft carriers (but not enough planes, but that's for a different time). Why aren't they being deployed?

Because the UK isn't really in the war, and doesn't want to be?

torawaytoday at 3:28 PM

They move a carrier into a vulnerable position in the Strait, where an attack by a tiny boat could both result in causalities and draw the UK into another protracted war in the Middle East with no clear exit condition and even more casualties?

And for what, exactly, a pat on the back from Trump? (who will then inevitably turn on them after a week and blame them for anything that goes wrong in the war.)

If escorting ship traffic was so straightforward with only upside, the US would be doing it already. Instead of trying to get someone else to take that risk.

blitzartoday at 2:47 PM

> this war

There is no war; there is a speical military operation, an excursion or a preemptive retaliatory defensive strike.

lkramertoday at 5:12 PM

Because even the UK is getting fed up with Trump? They literally started preparing to deploy on of the carriers to the Gulf and Trump basically told them to fuck off because they were "late" to the war? Now he's changed his mind again, who gives a damn? He can reap what he has sowed.

detarotoday at 2:25 PM

deploy and do what exactly? Get involved and potentially sacrifice a few UK soldiers to stroke Trumps ego? Sit around and look pretty? Having a carrier there doesn't magically make problems go away.

show 2 replies
Ekarostoday at 2:22 PM

You do not put your resources in danger unless you are actually ready to commit to it. And I mean possible loss of them and then entering to much hotter war.