logoalt Hacker News

throwawaypathlast Friday at 4:59 PM1 replyview on HN

>But because you believe this, you yourself believe in ontological evil, and therefore are ontologically evil.

Observing Islam does not make one Islamic. Observing ontological evil does not make one ontological evil.

>Weird flex but OK.

Dumb flex but OK.


Replies

krapplast Friday at 5:12 PM

>Observing Islam does not make one Islamic. Observing ontological evil does not make one ontological evil.

No, by your own words, "People who believe in ontological[sic] evil are ontologically evil people"

If you believe that Islam is ontologically evil, you believe in ontological evil.

Ipso facto you are an ontologically evil person.

This is basic kindergarten logic if it doesn't get through to you I don't know what to say.

"Observing Islam does not make one Islamic" is not an equivalent statement. You did not make a subjective statement about observation, you made an objective statement about belief.

>Dumb flex but OK.

I agree. It was dumb - "only Sith deal in absolutes" level stupid, and I don't know why you came back to double down on it.

show 1 reply