logoalt Hacker News

whatever1today at 2:12 PM4 repliesview on HN

Of course you can reduce highways and infrastructure and reduce traffic. But you also choked access to the city.

And no public transportation does not fix the problem. It helps a bit, but at the end of the day biggest part of far commuters are gradually cut off.

If decentralization is the target, then just state it.


Replies

goda90today at 2:22 PM

Many cities in the world have many thousands of far commuters arriving by train every day. And many of those people even live in single family homes and own cars.

rsynnotttoday at 3:06 PM

I would assume that if you’re commuting to Paris from far away, the train is generally _quicker_, tbh. AIUI the RER is mostly 140km/h quality lines.

Zigurdtoday at 2:30 PM

> choked access to the city

Citation needed.

Pedestrian and cyclist friendly cities have more vibrant street life, and are more attractive places to live. I've never heard of car restrictions leading to more suburbanization.

aaron695today at 2:45 PM

[dead]