logoalt Hacker News

bdangubicyesterday at 5:37 PM5 repliesview on HN

that would be stupid and their regime is not stupid


Replies

brepppyesterday at 5:46 PM

Hardly, after attacking all their friends in the region, which would leave them even more isolated after the war, I would not attribute careful strategic planning either

show 2 replies
jopsenyesterday at 6:06 PM

Do you think launching a dumb ICBM at New York would make the US put boots on the ground.

I kind of doubt it's enough. This wouldn't be another 9/11, it would be merely be retaliation.

show 4 replies
JumpCrisscrossyesterday at 7:11 PM

> their regime is not stupid

It’s pretty fucking stupid. Convening the top brass above ground, failing to scatter the navy, bombing Azerbaijan and Qatar and Oman. I’m not saying the individual actors are dumb. But the result of the competing centers of power between the IRGC, military proper, clerical establishment and god knows who else produces a stupid strategy.

show 1 reply
PixyMisayesterday at 7:26 PM

Their regime is made up of hardline Shia Twelvers that believe that if they kill enough people the Twelfth Imam will appear and lead them to global victory.

Only problem is the Twelfth Imam has been dead for a thousand years.

They may not be stupid, but they consistently act based on counterfactual beliefs.

9991yesterday at 6:07 PM

They're Muslims. You can debate whether that means 'stupid', but they've come to totally erroneous opinions on the structure of reality.

show 3 replies