logoalt Hacker News

SV_BubbleTimetoday at 3:28 AM3 repliesview on HN

IDK… I don’t care.

I think there is an unheard number of people that think vibe coding is fucking stupid and knows it doesn’t work. While also being really thankful for the small task automation that AI nails every single time.

Why does it have to be a world changing life altering experience? Why can’t I just like have a really helpful rubber duck that will find all the missing references or clean up merge issues for me?


Replies

shigawiretoday at 3:31 AM

> Why does it have to be a world changing life altering experience?

Because the global economy has been wagered on this

show 1 reply
zdragnartoday at 3:49 AM

The cost of growing and running large LLMs far exceeds the economic value of small task automation.

Small, targeted, on-device, cheap to run models make sense in some places. General purpose LLMs that take many gigawatt data centers to lose money producing questionable output don't.

We are finding ourselves simultaneously trying to divest from fossil fuels while increasing our energy consumption faster than ever. What are we getting for it? Slop, sycophantic rubber ducks, and merge conflict Clippy.

show 1 reply
altmanaltmantoday at 5:16 AM

> Why does it have to be a world changing life altering experience?

Because of the amount of money riding on it to be a life/world-altering experience. A really helpful rubber duck is not worth the cost. The dreams of AGI is. This is from a stock market pov not dev, but market narratives dominate in the mainstream, not tech.