logoalt Hacker News

ryandraketoday at 5:21 AM1 replyview on HN

It’s also an argument for quackery and snake oil, as long as the salesman declares “some people said it works!”

“People should be allowed bodily autonomy to take whatever chemicals they want” easily and dangerously turns into “People should be able to advertise and sell miracle cures that don’t work as long as their victims are gullible.”

Every snake oil fraudster hides their fraud behind principles like bodily autonomy.


Replies

Jachtoday at 12:38 PM

There is already much snake oil sales and marketing going on, it's already enabled by arguments that are not based on bodily autonomy, which suggests that a move towards more respect to bodily autonomy will not noticeably increase such snake oil. The resistance to homeopathy has not gone well. I actually believe the resistance is actively harmed by making legit chemicals harder to get instead of easier. When people can easily get the good stuff that works there's not much of a market for the easy to get snake oil that doesn't.