logoalt Hacker News

noduermetoday at 11:12 AM3 repliesview on HN

So what's left of the Iranian regime is basically like the Houthis now, reduced to getting world attention by committing random acts of piracy and firing at random ships off their coast. To make whatever point they were trying to make. Seems like a win to me. Declare victory, say the straight is open, just like the Red Sea is open. If anything moves at shipping, destroy its source. They don't have a right to attack merchant vessels, and there's no reason to negotiate with them either.


Replies

none2585today at 12:59 PM

> They don't have a right to attack merchant vessels

This is a sovereign nation that is being attacked by a waning superpower. It's war and they are retaliating in really the only way that they can force America to back off - which is make the war really expensive and even more unpopular domestically.

samustoday at 1:46 PM

> Declare victory, say the straight is open, just like the Red Sea is open. If anything moves at shipping, destroy its source.

Do you understand the concept of asymmetrical warfare? Hiding hundreds of launchers, firing them, and losing them is already accounted for by Iran, while a decent chance of losing any asset going through is prohibitively expensive. The strait is closed.

zyx321today at 4:15 PM

That sounds a lot like "do the thing you've been trying and failing for the past few weeks, but this time succeed instead of failing"