logoalt Hacker News

rejhgadellaatoday at 4:24 PM1 replyview on HN

The difference is that, on iOS, you can't switch to a different browser that does support these features. Om very other OS you can.

A web app could ask you to use a different browser (not ideal, but if the web app requires a specific API, it's not an unreasonable).

Safari is in a very special position because it controls what the web can do on iOS (all browsers on iOS have to use Apple's WebKit engine, they can't add web features). Apple is not just gatekeeping native (through the app store), but its competition, too (the open web, through the webkit requirement)


Replies

nerdjontoday at 4:33 PM

True, but putting aside that limitation on iOS for a moment.

The very important part about this is whether or not these features are actually considered a web standard or is it Google pushing their own agenda.

Which is where whether or not any non chromium browser supports any of these on any platform. Which many of these features they don't.

That completely changes the conversation here, from Apple purposefully ignoring standards to Google pushing things that are not standards yet. Which I will admit that the reality is a bit of both here, but it should not be considered a negative when a browser does not support a feature that is non standard... we heavily criticized IE for exactly this and yet we celebrate Chrome for it?

show 1 reply