Even if you don’t use p4merge, you can set Git’s merge.conflictStyle config to "diff3" or "zdiff3" (https://git-scm.com/docs/git-config#Documentation/git-config...). If you do that, Git’s conflict markers show the base version as well:

  <<<<<<< left
  ||||||| base
  def calculate(x):
      a = x * 2
      b = a + 1
      return b
  =======
  def calculate(x):
      a = x * 2
      logger.debug(f"a={a}")
      b = a + 1
      return b
  >>>>>>> right

> I don't understand why you need to switch out the VCS to fix that issue.

For some reason, when it comes to this subject, most people don't think about the problem as much as they think they've thought about it.

I recently listened to an episode on a well-liked and respected podcast featuring a guest there to talk about version control systems—including their own new one they were there to promote—and what factors make their industry different from other subfields of software development, and why a new approach to version control was needed. They came across as thoughtful but exasperated with the status quo and brought up issues worthy of consideration while mostly sticking to high-level claims. But after something like a half hour or 45 minutes into the episode, as they were preparing to descend from the high level and get into the nitty gritty of their new VCS, they made an offhand comment contrasting its abilities with Git's, referencing Git's approach/design wrt how it "stores diffs" between revisions of a file. I was bowled over.

For someone to be in that position and not have done even a cursory amount of research before embarking on a months (years) long project to design, implement, and then go on the talk circuit to present their VCS really highlighted that the familiar strain of NIH is still alive, even in the current era where it's become a norm for people to be downright resistant to writing a couple dozen lines of code themselves if there is no existing package to import from NPM/Cargo/PyPI/whatever that purports to solve the problem.

Seconding the use of p4merge for easy-to-use three-pane merging. Just like most other issues with Git, if your merges are painful it's probably due to terrible native UX design - not due to anything conceptually wrong with Git.