logoalt Hacker News

infinitewarsyesterday at 5:47 PM6 repliesview on HN

> more than 1 plane every minute

Software routinely solves database coordination problems with millions of users per second.


Replies

infinitewarsyesterday at 5:52 PM

I'm pretty sure the amount of data isn't the problem here. Maybe it's the number of corner cases? You would still want some human-in-the loop with quality UI for ATC.

show 1 reply
mongolyesterday at 5:53 PM

True. But to avoid 1 minute unavailability per year requires 99.9999 % availability

show 1 reply
yifanlyesterday at 6:18 PM

In a digitized environment. We cannot yet simulate the real world.

PunchyHamsteryesterday at 6:17 PM

with extremely controlled conditions. There is no fog in database, nor fallible humans involved, What an ignorant response

glitchcyesterday at 5:49 PM

Yup, by having backup runways.

show 2 replies
johnbarronyesterday at 6:02 PM

>> Software routinely solves database coordination problems with millions of users per second.

A naive view that confuses the map with the territory.

While in a database state you write a row and reality updates atomically....for aircraft they exist in a physical world where your model lives with lag, noise, and lossy sensors, and that world keeps moving whether your software is watching or not. Failed database transactions roll back, a landing clearance issued against stale state does not. The hard problem in ATC is not coordination logic but physical objects with momentum, human agency, and failure modes that do not respect your consistency model.