with all-matches semantics it returns a significantly higher number of matches than leftmost greedy.

eg. /abc*/ and abccccc will return you matches at ab|c|c|c|c|c|

I think it's very common and ok that people reason about other engines in terms of backtracking but it works very differently. And fixed length lookbehinds are more of a Java/Python thing, other engines support all lookbehinds.

The main idea of linear regex and intuitive semantics is that it should be declarative and the engine does whatever is the fastest without you having to worry about it. Instead of describing character by character how to perform the search and where it can blow up, think of it as just a specification. Then you can truly express whatever is the shortest/most convenient to explain.

Something i'm still trying to figure out and perhaps failing to understand is what are the killer features of backtracking regex that you would really miss if you were to use linear regex? It would help me a lot to know, i'm trying to convince others to make the switch