logoalt Hacker News

mnkyprskbdyesterday at 11:29 PM3 repliesview on HN

Currency isn't a homebrew computer or backyard car project; it is either centralised or not; there is no in between.

Blockchain with central authority is the worst of both worlds.


Replies

sota_popyesterday at 11:51 PM

Very much this, it’s all the technical rigour, code debt, and none of controls/reversibility.

At least when I report fraud to credit card or my bank, they can stop or undo/chargeback a transaction.

stan3223yesterday at 11:44 PM

And if it is centralised, what is the point of blockchain? Just run it out a Postgres database.

0x3fyesterday at 11:31 PM

Not really. At a traditional bank I have to trust n people with varying degrees of access. Et ceteris paribus, any reduction in n is an improvement, even if n is not zero.

Of course n can be smaller and the specific people less trustworthy, but that's quite a different thing.

show 4 replies