logoalt Hacker News

razorbeamzyesterday at 6:18 AM2 repliesview on HN

Next-token-prediction cannot do calculations. That is fundamental.

It can produce outputs that resemble calculations.

It can prompt an agent to input some numbers into a separate program that will do calculations for it and then return them as a prompt.

Neither of these are calculations.


Replies

gf000yesterday at 7:35 AM

So you don't think 50T parameter neural networks can encode the logic for adding two n-bit integers for reasonably sized integers? That would be pretty sad.

show 1 reply
parasubvertyesterday at 6:22 AM

Humans can't do calculations either, by your definition. Only computers can.

show 1 reply