logoalt Hacker News

jmalickitoday at 1:15 PM5 repliesview on HN

If they didn't cite your paper that's bullshit.

But if they read your paper enough that they invited you to a talk, that probably means they were far enough along to independently inventing it they were going to do so anyway, and wanted to chat with someone who was also doing the thing they were already doing. Good ideas tend to reveal themselves to anyone who is aware of the problem.


Replies

amitporttoday at 2:20 PM

To be clear, I am not claiming they stole an idea. They have made significant independent research. However, a specific part regarding the treatment of rotation with bias correction relates to prior work, and it would be appropriate to have that recognized.

CyberDildonicstoday at 4:29 PM

That's rationalizing like crazy. If they knew about it they should have cited it.

ekjhgkejhgktoday at 1:34 PM

Doesn't matter, you should still cite. It's basic manners in science.

show 1 reply
efavdbtoday at 2:18 PM

The earlier paper was from 2021!

cubefoxtoday at 2:10 PM

> But if they read your paper enough that they invited you to a talk, that probably means they were far enough along to independently inventing it

That's more than a stretch. They likely invited them because someone thought the abstract sounded interesting, or something like that.