logoalt Hacker News

GCUMstlyHarmlstoday at 3:52 AM1 replyview on HN

Is it? Stopping is a matter of ground swell support contacting representatives and saying "please don't". Enough people do it to enough receptive reps and they'll vote no.

Passing new ones that "you like" requires lawyers to write laws, get those laws in front of reps, get them to agree to try and pass it, stake some of their reputation on pushing it, get the ground swell to support it -- which might be difficult when the current law is "dont scan messages", you can easily say "hey dont scan anything! support that!" vs "hey scan somethings sometimes", cause many people will call that a slippery slope. I don't see how they are at all the same process.


Replies

thaumasiotestoday at 6:34 AM

Stopping legislation means organizing a sufficient number of no votes.

Passing it means organizing a sufficient number of yes votes.

They are the same process and they require exactly the same work. They take place at the exact same moment in time and space, although they are mutually exclusive.

You're free to describe things however you want, but your descriptions won't change the underlying reality.

show 3 replies