logoalt Hacker News

ck2yesterday at 5:49 PM2 repliesview on HN

The easiest way to explain this nonsense

is that in 100+ years of Olympics, there are ZERO elite athletes who were transgender

none

it's brought to you by the some of the very same people who want you to prove you are a citizen every time you vote

because there have been no previous cases of that either

However there are women who have given birth who will fail that SRY test

Because biology is messy, not black and white, never "on" or "off", there is always overlap

They tried this before in 1996 and quickly ended it by 2000 because the result was a disaster


Replies

qu4z-2yesterday at 10:36 PM

> it's brought to you by the some of the very same people who want you to prove you are a citizen every time you vote

I'm staying out of the other issue as best I can, but as a non-American the resistance to this is just baffling, especially given the fact your recent elections have not exactly been widely trusted internally. Not that I'm saying there was much merit to the distrust, but it still makes sense to take steps to demonstrate it. Caesar's wife must be above suspicion.

show 1 reply
gpmyesterday at 10:24 PM

There's also cis-male people who will "pass" that SRY test if they take it for some reason...

This is a dumb ass way to try and define the woman's category... which is about the expected result of bigots trying to work backwards from the result they want headlines about.

show 1 reply