logoalt Hacker News

pcthrowawayyesterday at 9:39 PM4 repliesview on HN

Building part of a killing machine isn't really something you can defend, even if you weren't working on the part of the machine that does the killing.


Replies

JumpCrisscrossyesterday at 9:52 PM

> Building part of a killing machine isn't really something you can defend

Of course it is. I don't personally have an issue with folks who worked on weapons of war. Particularly if they're honest with themselves about the work they did. Doubly particularly if they felt a sense of mission in it.

And in an integrated culture and economy, the difference between a person who happens to work at a company with an evil project in a random division and a person who grows complacent about politics with their non-problematic job is thin to the point of vanishing.

bombcartoday at 3:20 AM

What part? If you work on the manufacturing line for bolts, and one of the ten thousand bolts your company makes is sometimes used in cruise missiles, are you a munitions worker?

I think you're likely trying to say "the guy who wrote the positioning code" is as much a killing machine maker as the guy who loaded the explosives.

zeroonetwothreetoday at 1:13 AM

We all live in glass houses

hunterpaynetoday at 1:14 AM

Do me a favor. Go to Ukraine with someone who worked on the Javelin anti-tank missile and tell them that. I bet the guy who worked on the Javelin will be considered a hero. You will likely receive a kick in the balls for ever daring to criticize him or repeating your post. Your take is naive in the extreme.