logoalt Hacker News

CyberDildonicsyesterday at 10:55 PM1 replyview on HN

ICE car fires are easier to put out.

When did one crash into a building, catch on fire, and kill people? Surely this must have happened at some point for you to put all this together.

Which part of any of this is straining your imagination?

The part where it never came close to happening after and you changed what you're saying.

It's only a matter of time before an EV catches fire after crashing into a building and a bunch of people die

It's only a matter of time before someone gets hit by lightning after winning the lottery too.


Replies

fluoridationyesterday at 11:28 PM

>When did one crash into a building, catch on fire, and kill people? Surely this must have happened at some point for you to put all this together.

You can't think of a single example of an ICE vehicle crashing into a building, starting a fire, and a bunch of people dying? I can think of two such crashes happening the same day, involving jet engines.

I don't know why this is relevant, though. The topic of discussion is lithium batteries, not ICEs. A vehicle crashing into a building and starting a fire that kills people is not some science fiction scenario that should need to be defended. Your incredulity is straying into bad faith territory.

>you changed what you're saying

I changed it because I think it's it's pretty obvious that the concerning thing is the EV catching fire where it can easily spread to other things. Whether that's because the vehicle crashed or for some other reason is inconsequential. The reason I gave that example initially was because that's just what I happened to have in mind at the time; it makes sense that a crash could damage the batteries enough to cause a thermal runaway, rather than the car randomly bursting into flames for no reason.

>It's only a matter of time before someone gets hit by lightning after winning the lottery too.

Winning the lottery doesn't increase your chances of getting hit by lightning, nor vice versa, but crashing your EV does increase the chances that it can catch fire, and a building is one of the things it can crash into. Having a fire that cannot be put out likewise increases the chances that someone may die from it, compared to if the fire is easily to be put out.

I don't know, do you really find it that unreasonable to be a little bit concerned that cars now have these giant energy stores that if they fail they're impossible to control until they burn out completely?

show 1 reply