logoalt Hacker News

WalterBrighttoday at 12:54 AM2 repliesview on HN

> It does both!

No, it does not concentrate wealth. Wealth is not a fixed pie. In a free market, you get wealthy by creating wealth, not concentrating it.

As for monopolies, competition is what prevents them.


Replies

krastanovtoday at 1:30 AM

This sounds incredibly naive. Competition does not magically prevent monopolies -- once you have a dominant player they just buy or undercut the occasional competing startup.

show 1 reply
CPLXtoday at 1:52 AM

Unregulated capitalism inevitably trends towards a mafia state with an oligarchic structure and concentrated monopolistic power. It’s just an empirical fact at this point.

The engine that really drives innovation and wealth creation is regulated capitalism that preserves competitive markets by restraining anticompetitive behavior.

If you’re ideologically attached to capitalism I have good news for you. That’s the approach that leads to its most effective implementation.

If you’re ideologically attached to “market fundamentalism” as I suspect, which is a reflexive opposition to regulation, then this concentrated market structure is what you’re advocating for.

show 1 reply