logoalt Hacker News

allreduceyesterday at 3:39 PM1 replyview on HN

> And those people are given the escape hatch of "transness" which is a lie politely allowed by society which gives people the delusion of trying to be what they cannot ever be.

I'm arguing that it ought not to be a polite lie if there are people whose mental makeup is better suited to a gender expression not corresponding to their sex, who then inhabit that different role in everyday life. I frankly don't get your assertion that this cannot happen, as there exist people for whom this is reality right now (in part because they are simply not easily identifyable as trans).

> young people are mutilating themselves and crippling themselves irreversibly by using hormones

My understanding is that the worst side-effect of using hormones is infertility, while surgery comes with more risks.

Anyway, it's about trading off mental anguish against possible complications of medical intervention. Where is the problem here? People do cosmetic surgeries for similar, if not more vain, reasons.

> when doctors try to treat these people correctly, according to their true nature (sex), trans activists have attacked the doctors calling it "misgendering"

Trying to ignore the reality that ones body is different in medical contexts would be indeed harmful. If this kind of activism exists, I do not condone it. I imagine that treating a trans person does not boil down to treating them like a cis person of their sex however, as hormone replacement causes a bunch of differences.


Replies

ragallyesterday at 3:55 PM

> I'm arguing that it ought not to be a polite lie

A lie is defined in terms of it not being the truth, not in terms of effects on someone. Those effects are entirely irrelevant.

> My understanding is that the worst side-effect of using hormones is infertility, while surgery comes with more risks.

Men getting oestrogens are getting osteoporosis in their 20's and 30's.

> Anyway, it's about trading off mental anguish against possible complications of medical intervention.

It's not even doing that in most cases, because the self-loathing that caused people to look for the "transness" escape hatch turns out to have outside causes and won't go away.

show 1 reply