logoalt Hacker News

Shankyesterday at 5:20 PM5 repliesview on HN

Page 7 [0] of the report seems to indicate that FGM reconstruction actually seems to have negative outcomes post-surgery. I'm surprised by this. I'm also shocked to see how prolific FGM is too (230 million women?!).

[0]: https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.64898/2026.03.18.712572v1...


Replies

05yesterday at 8:42 PM

> seems to indicate that FGM reconstruction actually seems to have negative outcomes post-surgery.

> Longitudinal data indicate that approximately 22% of women who undergo clitoral reconstruction experience a post-operative decline in orgasmic experience [25, 26]

From [25] abstract: Most patients reported an improvement, or at least no worsening, in pain (821 of 840 patients) and clitoral pleasure (815 of 834 patients)

So, I think the quote needs to be interpreted as surgery, even though beneficial on average, still having a pretty high percentage of negative outcomes (22%) and nerve mapping potentially helping reduce that.

hammockyesterday at 11:36 PM

>230 million women

500,000 in the USA. 98%+ in some other countries. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prevalence_of_female_genital_m...

turkey99yesterday at 6:11 PM

Male genital mutilation is very common

show 3 replies
TacticalCoderyesterday at 11:11 PM

> I'm also shocked to see how prolific FGM is too (230 million women?!)

And talk to any gyn doc in the west: it's happening among those communities in the west too (but on a lesser scale). In several EU western countries the most common gynelogical surgery act is re-building the hymen (so that the woman can pretend she's a virgin once she marries, often forcibly by her family). You may not have gyn doctors friend but I do. And midwives. And they know.

"... surveys show that the practice of FGM is highly concentrated in a swath of countries from the Atlantic coast to the Horn of Africa, in areas of the Middle East such as Iraq and Yemen and in some countries in Asia like Indonesia, with wide variations in prevalence. The practice is almost universal in Somalia, Guinea and Djibouti, with levels of 90 per cent or higher, while it affects no more than 1 per cent of girls and women in Cameroon and Uganda"

Now from Wikipedia:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religious_views_on_female_geni...

"FGM is practised predominantly within certain Muslim societies,[13] but it also exists within some adjacent Christian and animist groups.[14] The practice is not required by Islam and fatwas have been issued forbidding FGM,[15] favouring it,[16] or leaving the decision to parents but advising against it."

Let's call a cat: of these 230 mutilated women, a vast majority are muslims. There are 900 million muslim women on earth and nearly 1/4th of them have been mutilated by their community.

Ponder this.

thomastjefferyyesterday at 8:39 PM

Surgery is essentially mutilation, just with a lot of effort to get the patient a positive outcome. Hopefully, this information will help.