alt Hacker NewsTo me, the most important feature of Cargo isn't even the dependency management but that I don't ever need to tell it which files to compile or where to find them. The fact that it knows to look for lib.rs or main.rs in src and then recursively find all my other modules without me needing to specify targets or anything like that is a killer feature on its own IMO. Over the past couple of years I've tried to clone and build a number of dotnet packages for various things, but for an ecosystem that's supposedly cross-platform, almost none of them seem to just work by default when I run `dotnet build` and instead require at least some fixes in the various project files. I don't think I've ever had an issue with a Rust project, and it's hard not to feel like a big part of that is because there's not really much configuration to be done. The list of dependencies is just about the only thing in there that effects the default build; if there's any other configuration other than that and the basic metadata like the name, the repo link, the license, etc., it almost always will end up being specifically for alternate builds (like extra options for release builds, alternate features that can be compiled in, etc.).
Replies
> I don't think I've ever had an issue with a Rust project, and it's hard not to feel like a big part of that is because there's not really much configuration to be done.
For most crates, yes. But you might be surprised how many crates have a build.rs that is doing more complex stuff under the hood (generating code, setting environment variables, calling a C compiler, make or some other build system, etc). It just also almost always works flawlessly (and the script itself has a standardised name), so you don't notice most of the time.
But you are specifying source files, although indirectly, aren't you? That's what all those `mod blah` with a corresponding `blah.rs` file present in the correct location are.
For me the lack of dependency hell until I hit a c/c++ component somewhere in the build is the real winner.
Yep ... go/zig pkg management has the same benefit compared to c/c++.
> The fact that it knows to look for lib.rs or main.rs in src and then recursively find all my other modules without me needing to specify targets or anything like that is a killer feature on its own IMO.
In the interest of pedantry, locating source files relative to the crate root is a language-level Rust feature, not something specific to Cargo. You can pass any single Rust source file directly to rustc (bypassing Cargo altogether) and it will treat it as a crate root and locate additional files as needed based on the normal lookup rules.