logoalt Hacker News

ralferootoday at 9:28 AM1 replyview on HN

Seems nice, but beyond 6 points the polygons are hard to distinguish easily. Certainly not something you can quickly glance at in a rush. I'd say sticking to 5 maximum would be best.

I don't think empty for 0 necessarily makes the best sense. You wouldn't easily be able to see where the gaps are at a distance.

Using base 60 and encoding digits doesn't necessarily make the most sense.

For instance hours, it might make sense to use 2x times base 5, probably with no 0 encoded so that there's always something in the hours column.

Or, of course you could do an encoding with a base 4 and a base 6, which is mentally easy to convert back to to a regular 24 hour clock. TBH I'd probably encode that as maybe a square where there's 1-4 sides enclosing a polygon of 0-5 points.

Maybe I'd encode half-minutes with 3 base 5 encodings and some encodings unused, or a base 3, base 4 and a base 5 encoding for minutes.

I would probably also then group them into functional groups that touch each other within the group, so you can easily see the groups, but tell them apart easily.


Replies

ralferootoday at 9:48 AM

Actually, I was going to completely edit this comment with a different suggestion, but decided to leave that to show the thought process.

Thinking more about the hours, I like the circle progressing round, but also maybe you could do it as a box with 1-4 sides present enclosing a polygon of 0-5 points. It's easy to mentally convert that to both 12 and 24 hour clock format.

For the minutes, I'd be tempted to do something like the current hours, done as a fraction of the circle arc with an additional polygon of 0-5 points for the minute. It's relatively easy to eyeball the size of the 5 minute segment, and the polygon just refines that a bit. You could locate the polygon so it touches the arc at the 1/12 of the circle corresponding to the base, which would help with estimating the arc length too.

Either way, I wouldn't make the encoding rely on colours, especially colours that look very similar.