logoalt Hacker News

Forgeties79today at 3:58 PM1 replyview on HN

> Whoever is submitting the code is still responsible for it, why would the reviewer care if you wrote it with your fingers or if an LLM wrote (parts of) it?

Maybe one day we can say that, but currently, it matters a lot to a lot of people for many reasons.


Replies

yarn_today at 4:09 PM

> Likewise, leaving AI attribution in will probably have the opposite effect as well, where a perfectly good few lines of code gets rejected because some reviewer saw it was claude and assumed it was slop. Neither of these cases seems helpful to anyone (obviously its not like AI can't write a single useable line of code)."

That was my point here, it is a false signal in both directions.

show 1 reply