logoalt Hacker News

dummydummy1234yesterday at 7:31 PM1 replyview on HN

I have found the one of the better use cases of llms to be a rubber duck.

Explaining a design, problem, etc and trying to find solutions is extremely useful.

I can bring novelty, what I often want from the LLM is a better understanding of the edge cases that I may run into, and possible solutions.


Replies

monkaijuyesterday at 7:48 PM

I always find folks bringing up rubber ducking as a thing LLMs are good at to be misguided. IMO, what defines rubber ducking as a concept is that it is just the developer explaining what their doing to themselves. Not to another person, and not to a thing pretending to be a person. If you have a "two way" or "conversational" debugging/designing experience it isnt rubber ducking, its just normal design/debugging.

The moment I bring in a conversational element, I want a being that actually has problem comprehension and creativity which an LLM by definition does not.

show 5 replies