logoalt Hacker News

erutoday at 6:19 AM6 repliesview on HN

Have you heard of opportunity costs?

About war: in our universe we got the first digital computers because of military efforts during the second world war. However, without a war IBM and Konrad Zuse and others would have gotten there, too. With much less human suffering.


Replies

TheOtherHobbestoday at 9:47 AM

It's unlikely computing would have developed as quickly as it did without the Cold War. IBM's Sage and MIT's TX0 were both Cold War projects - one for a national early warning system, the other as an R&D platform for flight simulators.

Most US investment in associated tech - including the Internet - came through DARPA.

Not pointing this out because I support war, but to underline that the US doesn't have a culture of aggressive government investment in non-military R&D.

NASA and the NSF both get pocket money in budget terms. And at its height Apollo was a Cold War PR battle with the USSR that happened to funnel a lot of of money to defence contractors.

The original moon landings were not primarily motivated by science.

show 1 reply
necovektoday at 6:35 AM

I believe you are making the same argument: the GP prefers space race over war for large technological development at less or no human suffering.

show 2 replies
fastballtoday at 7:11 AM

What opportunity is being lost out on because of space exploration?

show 1 reply
TeMPOraLtoday at 1:40 PM

You are serious? Up until this point I thought you're writing in jest, because all the things you mention are actually good ideas - including especially funding manned space flight from entertainment budget, because:

1) It's better aligned with mission profile (inspirational, emotional, but not strictly necessary;

2) There's much more of it to go than NASA gets;

3) It would be a better use of that money than what it's currently used for.

show 1 reply
gmerctoday at 8:28 AM

Now do the opportunity cost of AI model virtue signalling to investors for several years

show 1 reply
YetAnotherNicktoday at 7:59 AM

Firstly how is this related to opportunity costs. Secondly, no one said that to create digital computer you should start a war. It's just that war is already present, regardless of you invent digital computers or space travel.