logoalt Hacker News

paulmooreparkstoday at 6:26 AM2 repliesview on HN

Interesting moral discussion: An estimated 8000 fewer births in 2017 attributed to a law that saved an estimated 57 lives in the same year.


Replies

kelnostoday at 9:33 AM

It's also unclear if it's the laws alone that saved those 57 kids. If the laws didn't exist, presumably some of those 57 kids would still have been in rear-facing child seats, and would have survived, no? (Unless their study accounted for that, and the end result was 57.)

But it is an interesting thing to think about. Sure, 57 children dying would create a lot of misery for a family (and extended family), but would 8,000 other children in the world, presumably giving their families happiness, somehow "make up for it"?

Feels odd to think about it in those terms. Balancing/trading lives is a dirty business.

etamponitoday at 6:53 AM

It's the classical trolley problem.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trolley_problem

show 2 replies