logoalt Hacker News

goodcanadiantoday at 9:14 AM2 repliesview on HN

There are actually a lot of really interesting discoveries on that list. I haven't thought deeply about whether it represents value for money, but I would say that that is anything but "a joke of a list."


Replies

erutoday at 11:52 AM

And 'Stimulating the low-Earth orbit economy' is a joke. Spending money not as a means to an end, but as the end in itself?

Apart from the research into the effects of microgravity on humans, pretty much everything else could have been done cheaper and better without humans.

Or take this example:

> Deployment of CubeSats from station: CubeSats are one of the smallest types of satellites and provide a cheaper way to perform science and technology demonstrations in space. More than 250 CubeSats have now been deployed from the space station, jumpstarting research and satellite companies.

Cubesats are great! But you don't exactly need a manned space station to deploy them. Similar with many other 'achievements' like the 'Alpha Magnetic Spectrometer'.

See also how they don't mention any actual impact. Only stuff like "This achievement may provide insight into fundamental laws of quantum mechanics."

And this is supposed to be the list of highlights. The best they have to offer.

show 1 reply
extraduder_iretoday at 1:30 PM

Also, it's NASA, so they can't come out and say "stopped soviet rocket technology and expertise from proliferating" which was a large motivator for the ISS.