logoalt Hacker News

jandrewrogerstoday at 4:16 AM0 repliesview on HN

Your scenario imagines a naive and completely fictional concept of how modern naval systems actually work. That you can’t conceive of why what you are suggesting is effectively impossible means you truly don’t understand the domain.

The reason designed-for-purpose anti-ship missiles/drones are so expensive is they are literally designed to be somewhat effective at executing exactly the scenario you are laying out, while not being naive about the defenses that military ships actually have. Anybody that understands the capability space knows that your scenario wouldn’t survive contact with real defenses.

You are making an argument from fiction. Do you take the “hackers breaking cryptography” trope from Hollywood at face value?