logoalt Hacker News

colechristensentoday at 1:27 PM4 repliesview on HN

This is silly. I can build products in a weekend that would take me a year by myself. I am still necessary 1% of the time for debug, design, and direction and those of not at all a shallow skill. I have some graduate algebra texts on the way my math friend is guiding me through because I have found a publishable result and need to shore up my background before writing the paper...

It's not perpetual motion, it's very real capability, you just have to be able to learn how to use it.


Replies

qseratoday at 1:41 PM

No one is saying that it cannot do what you say now.

What I am saying is that once the high quality training data runs out, it will drop in its capabilities pretty fast. That is how I compare it to perpetual motion mechanism scams. In the case of a perpetual motion machine, it appear that it will continue to run indefinitely. That is analogous to the impression that you have now. You feel that this will go on and on for ever, and that is the scam you are falling for.

show 2 replies
askafriendtoday at 1:30 PM

You can see their ego trying to protect itself.

coldteatoday at 2:01 PM

>This is silly. I can build products in a weekend that would take me a year by myself

Is the world any better for them existing? The decline of coding and sw engineering skills in humans from outsourcing the practice of it to AI is it worth it and sustainable long term?

show 1 reply
tpdlytoday at 1:34 PM

You're fooling yourself.

People yeating a (shitty) Github clone with Claude in a week apparently can't imagine it, but if you know the shit out of Rails, start with a good a boiler plate, and have a good git library, a solo dev can also build a (shitty) Github clone in a week. And they'll be able to take it somewhere, unlike the llm ratsnest that will require increasingly expensive tokens to (frustratingly) modify.

show 2 replies