logoalt Hacker News

kpw94today at 5:05 PM4 repliesview on HN

Wild differences in ELO compared to tfa's graph: https://storage.googleapis.com/gdm-deepmind-com-prod-public/...

(Comparing Q3.5-27B to G4 26B A4B and G4 31B specifically)

I'd assume Q3.5-35B-A3B would performe worse than the Q3.5 deep 27B model, but the cards you pasted above, somehow show that for ELO and TAU2 it's the other way around...

Very impressed by unsloth's team releasing the GGUF so quickly, if that's like the qwen 3.5, I'll wait a few more days in case they make a major update.

Overall great news if it's at parity or slightly better than Qwen 3.5 open weights, hope to see both of these evolve in the sub-32GB-RAM space. Disappointed in Mistral/Ministral being so far behind these US & Chinese models


Replies

coder543today at 5:19 PM

> Wild differences in ELO compared to tfa's graph

Because those are two different, completely independent Elos... the one you linked is for LMArena, not Codeforces.

nateb2022today at 5:31 PM

> Very impressed by unsloth's team releasing the GGUF so quickly, if that's like the qwen 3.5, I'll wait a few more days in case they make a major update.

Same here. I can't wait until mlx-community releases MLX optimized versions of these models as well, but happily running the GGUFs in the meantime!

Edit: And looks like some of them are up!

culitoday at 6:54 PM

You're conflating lmarena ELO scores.

Qwen actually has a higher ELO there. The top Pareto frontier open models are:

  model                        |elo  |price
  qwen3.5-397b-a17b            |1449 |$1.85
  glm-4.7                      |1443 | 1.41
  deepseek-v3.2-exp-thinking   |1425 | 0.38
  deepseek-v3.2                |1424 | 0.35
  mimo-v2-flash (non-thinking) |1393 | 0.24
  gemma-3-27b-it               |1365 | 0.14
  gemma-3-12b-it               |1341 | 0.11
  gpt-oss-20b                  |1318 | 0.09
  gemma-3n-e4b-it              |1318 | 0.03
https://arena.ai/leaderboard/text?viewBy=plot

What Gemma seems to have done is dominate the extreme cheap end of the market. Which IMO is probably the most important and overlooked segment

show 1 reply
gigatexaltoday at 6:15 PM

the benchmarks showing the "old" Chinese qwen models performing basically on par with this fancy new release kinda has me thinking the google models are DOA no? what am I missing?