logoalt Hacker News

ErroneousBoshtoday at 11:14 AM4 repliesview on HN

Okay, it immediately costs more to buy an EV than it does to run my existing car. The monthly payment to buy an EV is more than I spend on fuel.

Then I'd be paying roughly ten times as much for insurance, because it's a new and valuable car, and being "keyless" it cannot be secured in any meaningful way without locking it in a garage, which I don't have.

Because I don't have a garage or a driveway I can't park right at my house, so I would not be able to charge at home. So I'd have to park an EV up at the nearest charging point several miles away, cycle home, and then cycle back to the car to retrieve it. This would then be costing roughly the same per mile to charge it up as it costs per mile for propane (my car is dual-fuel).

That's before you add in the exorbitant cost of servicing an EV, which can only be done at a dealer.

All told, I'd be spending a grand a month to replace a vehicle that costs a couple of hundred a month, that - crucially - wouldn't allow me to actually do the things I need it to do.


Replies

Tade0today at 1:56 PM

First time I hear that all EVs are keyless and have expensive insurance.

What model were you considering and why only this one?

show 1 reply
Schiendelmantoday at 1:35 PM

Those are arguments, not math. Will you share your actual math?

show 2 replies
pmg101today at 11:50 AM

My insurance went down not up when I switched.

EV servicing is cheaper and I do it less often.

I bought used. The monthly depreciation is less than my previous fuel bill.

YMMV.

show 1 reply
zigman1today at 11:25 AM

> among people who like me can charge at home

OP said this, you clearly don't fall into this category. And if servicing an electric car costs more than servicing an old Landrover I will not eat for a week

show 1 reply