logoalt Hacker News

neonstatictoday at 1:54 AM2 repliesview on HN

> I can't imaging a point where I won't want to ask "what's the weather like?" "please turn off the lights"

To help with understanding that perspective, I cannot imagine a scenario where I would ask a device connected to the internet to turn off the lights. I literally never wanted this. A physical switch is a 100% non negotiable for me. I feel the same way about non-mechanical car doors.

Perhaps due to that outlook I was always puzzled about the entire idea of an "assistant". It's interesting for me to see, that there are people out there who actually want that "assistant".


Replies

Barbingtoday at 7:00 AM

The switch is a necessity.

Ever end up cooking or something when the phone/doorbell rings and you want to pause the music? Have your hands full and wanted to open a door? Hear the weather and then the news as you brew coffee or put your shoes on (without interaction with a bright screen)?

You should save some money and keep some privacy doing it your way :)

wat10000today at 3:32 AM

You don't watch Iron Man and want a JARVIS? Current systems are pretty far away from that, but that's the overall draw.

show 1 reply