logoalt Hacker News

NewJazzyesterday at 7:53 AM1 replyview on HN

How would that benefit anyone?...

The core feature of the senate that makes it so indefensible is how it assigns power to states, not people. That relationship cannot be amended, per article 5 of the us constitution.


Replies

themafiayesterday at 8:32 AM

It's far easier to change a state government than it is the federal government. The states used to be able to recall Senators if they failed to do their jobs correctly; as determined by the elected body within the state. It's simply a single level indirection of Democracy. The House of Representatives is direct. This was intentional.

What's "indefensible" about this?

And you can amend how the body is elected; hell, you can amend how the president is elected. Also Article V provides for a state "constitutional convention" as a process for initiating changes, bypassing both the Senate and the House.

show 1 reply