logoalt Hacker News

Mordisquitosyesterday at 4:41 PM1 replyview on HN

I only clicked on the article with no intention of reading it (no time), but rather out of morbid curiosity as to why on earth anybody would need to be told that LLMs should absolutely not be used to generate passwords.

> [...] Despite this, LLM-generated passwords appear in the real world – used by real users, and invisibly chosen by coding agents as part of code development tasks, instead of relying on traditional secure password generation methods.

Jesus F'ing Christ. I hope to have time to read the whole thing later.


Replies

sowbugyesterday at 4:52 PM

The article is a bit of a strawman, and a bit of an advertisement for a security consultancy. If you ask someone else to pick a password for you, then it's a secret known by two people. So don't do that. That was true a thousand* years ago. It's still true today.

*I know, I know, hash functions didn't exist on Earth a thousand years ago. Still true.

show 1 reply