logoalt Hacker News

elihuyesterday at 9:16 PM1 replyview on HN

I've been wondering for awhile about the economics of the AC vs DC grid thing. Historically, AC made a lot more sense because transformers are simple and relatively straightforward to make. But now we have amazing capabilities to handle enormous amounts of power with modern IGBTs and similar power-switching transistors. (A modern high-end EV motor controller, for instance, might be able to handle a megawatt of power. Not continuously, but still.) Is a DC-DC converter now more economically viable than an equivalent transformer? The former is more techincally complicated, but the latter is bulky and requires large quantities of expensive input materials like copper.


Replies

jschveibinzyesterday at 9:46 PM

Still roughly 2x the cost and about 10x lower MTBF.

show 2 replies