I enjoyed reading this. Thank you for sharing.

I learned Common Lisp years ago while working in the AI lab at the University of Toronto, and parts of this article resonated strongly with me.

However, if you abandon the idea of REPL-driven development, then the frontier models from Anthropic and OpenAI are actually very capable of writing Lisp code. They struggle sometimes editing it (messing up parens)), but usually the first pass is pretty good.

I've been on an LLM kick the past few months, and two of my favorite AI-coded (mostly) projects are, interestingly, REPL-focused. icl (https://github.com/atgreen/icl) is a TUI and browser-based front end for your CL REPL designed to make REPL programming for humans more fun, whether you use it stand-alone, or as an Emacs companion. Even more fun is whistler (https://github.com/atgreen/whistler), which allows you to write/compile/load eBPF code in lisp right from your REPL. In this case, the AI wrote the highly optimizing SSA-based compiler from scratch, and it is competitive against (and sometimes beating) clang -O2. I mean... I say the AI wrote it... but I had to tell it what I wanted in some detail. I start every project by generating a PRD, and then having multiple AIs review that until we all agree that it makes sense, is complete enough, and is the right approach to whatever I'm doing.