logoalt Hacker News

FrojoStoday at 1:24 PM1 replyview on HN

Every PhD program I'm aware of has a final hurdle known as the defence. You have to present your thesis while standing in front of a committee, and often the local community and public. They will asks questions and too many "I don't know" or false answers would make you fail. So, there is already a system in place that should stop Bob from graduating if he indeed learned much less than Alice. A similar argument can be made for conference publications. If Bob publishes his first year project at a conference but doesn't actually understand "his own work" it will show.

The difficulty of passing the defence vary's wildly between Universities, departments and committees. Some are very serious affairs with a decent chance of failure while others are more of a show event for friends and family. Mine was more of the latter, but I doubt I would have passed that day if I had spend the previous years prompting instead of doing the grunt work.


Replies

ipaddrtoday at 2:22 PM

In the future the llms can answer those questions for you by listening and feeding you answers into your headset.

The process you describe is a gate keeping exercise which will change to include llm judges at somepoint.

show 1 reply