logoalt Hacker News

sgbealtoday at 8:05 PM2 repliesview on HN

> There is actual research suggesting concise prompting can reduce response length substantially without always wrecking quality,

Anecdote: i discussed that with an LLM once and it explained to me that LLMs tend to respond to terse questions with terse answers because that's what humans (i.e. their training data) tend to do. Similarly, it explained to me that polite requests tend to lead to LLM responses with _more_ information than a response strictly requires because (again) that's what their training data suggests is correct (i.e. because that's how humans tend to respond).

TL;DR: how they are asked questions influences how they respond, even if the facts of the differing responses don't materially differ.

(Edit: Seriously, i do not understand the continued down-voting of completely topical responses. It's gotten so bad i have little choice but to assume it's a personal vendetta.)


Replies

sumenotoday at 9:21 PM

LLMs don't understand what they are doing, they can't explain it to you, it's just creating a reasonable sounding response

show 1 reply
laroditoday at 10:15 PM

this continual down-voting is not a personal thing for sure. perhaps there are crawlers that pretend to be more humane, or fully automated llm commenters which also randomly downvote.