logoalt Hacker News

HauntingPinyesterday at 10:22 PM3 repliesview on HN

Yes. What do you think happens in a competitive marketplace? Sony heard about Nintendo partnering up with Philips for the SNES CD expansion, so Sony made their own console. That's literally competition.

The details of how the "public pressure" came to be don't matter, because the monopoly didn't know about that. All they knew was there was a potential competitor, so they behaved according to that information. That's how it works.


Replies

karlgkkyesterday at 10:55 PM

Frankly, I think you're trying to poke holes in a straightforward concept. And now you've dug your heels in and you're trying to justify it. But... let's ignore opinions and interpretations...

> Sony heard about Nintendo partnering up with Philips for the SNES CD expansion, so Sony made their own console

This is completely inaccurate in every way possible. You even have the order of events backwards (Nintendo and Sony partnered first). There is in no way in which even the most charitable interpretation of this statement could bear out. Just about the only correct part is that you have some (but not all!) of the relevant parties involved.

If you're wrong about such a well documented, cut and dry matter of historical record, then what else are you wrong about? :)

show 1 reply
hrimfaxiyesterday at 11:39 PM

I don't understand this line of thinking. The spreading of a false rumor is an example of a competitive marketplace? If this took place in a different domain wouldn't it be fraud? That it was in the public benefit seems orthogonal.

show 2 replies