logoalt Hacker News

raw_anon_1111yesterday at 11:04 PM1 replyview on HN

This article is technically incorrect on so many levels I didn’t even bother to finish it.

1. There may be a territorial monopoly on cable. But there is nothing stopping other companies from laying fiber. There are areas - including where I use to live that had cable and the phone company laying fiber

2. Everyone on the internet is using a “shared” connection. The difference is whether it is shared at the last mile or upstream. If your ISP doesn’t provision enough upstream capacity, the last mile doesn’t matter.

3. Fiber is rarely shared at the last mile.

4. Just a little research says 25Gbps is not universal across Switzerland

5. When I did have AT&T Fiber that advertised at 1GB u/d, it didn’t slow down no matter what time of day.

Please don’t suffer from the Gell-Mann Amnesia Effect. M


Replies

ragalltoday at 4:26 AM

> But there is nothing stopping other companies from laying fiber.

Yes there is: the cost.

> Fiber is rarely shared at the last mile.

It is in Switzerland. That's the whole point of this setup.

> Just a little research says 25Gbps is not universal across Switzerland

It is in the big cities. Elsewhere the same arrangement is true, but on a lower scale.

show 1 reply