logoalt Hacker News

staticassertiontoday at 2:48 PM1 replyview on HN

> It's really not. A service adds complexity. If you have no reason to add it besides to "reduce complexity" - that is an oxymoron.

No, it really is. I can just as easily say that a system is simpler when it's composite parts are isolated, or that a system is simpler if I can take one component and reason about it in isolation, etc.

Similarly, I could say that libraries add or reduce complexity by making similar appeals like "a single unit of code is simpler" or "separate, smaller units are simpler" etc.


Replies

onlyrealcuzzotoday at 5:02 PM

> No, it really is. I can just as easily say that a system is simpler when it's composite parts are isolated

No, a system can not be simpler because you moved A' to B and introduced C (complexity - an added network, gateway, communication layer) for no reason besides to make the entire system simpler.

It is not simpler! You did nothing besides introduce C (complexity)!

show 1 reply