logoalt Hacker News

hombre_fatalyesterday at 7:14 PM1 replyview on HN

Also, many of the complaints seem more like giddy joy than anything.

The negative emotion regex, for example, is only used for a log/telemetry metric. Sampling "wtf?" along would probably be enough. Why would you use an agent for that?

I don't see how a vibe-coded app is freed from the same trade-offs that apply to a fast-moving human-coded one.

Especially since a human is still driving it, thus they will take the same shortcuts they did before: instead of a formal planning phase, they'll just yolo it with the agent. Instead of cleaning up technical debt, they want to fix specific issues that are easy to review, not touch 10 files to do a refactor that's hard to review. The highest priority issues are bugs and new integrations, not tech debt, just like it always was.

This is really just a reminder of how little upside there is to coding in the open.


Replies

kennywinkeryesterday at 7:24 PM

I think the thing is that people expect one of the largest companies in the world to have well written code.

Claude’s source code is fine for a 1-3 person team. It’s atrocious for a flagship product from a company valued over $380 BILLION.

Like if that’s the best ai coding can do given infinite money? Yeah, the emperor has no clothes. If it’s not the best that can be done, then what kinda clowns are running the show over there?

show 3 replies