logoalt Hacker News

einrealistyesterday at 11:39 PM4 repliesview on HN

I don't trust anyone who claims that LLMs today are superhumanly intelligent. All they do is perform compute-intensive brute-force attacks on the problem/solution space and call it 'reasoning', all while subsidising the real costs to capture the market. So much SciFi BS and extrapolation about a technology that is useful if adopted with care.

This technology needs to become a commodity to destroy this aggregation of power between a few organizations with untrustworthy incentives and leadership.


Replies

shruggedatlastoday at 12:19 AM

Your brain is performing "compute-intensive brute-force attacks on the problem/solution space" as you read this very sentence. You trained patterns on English syntax, structure, and semantics since you were a child and it is supporting you now with inference (or interpretation). And, for compute efficiency, you probably have evolution to thank.

show 4 replies
stavrostoday at 12:11 AM

> All they do is perform compute-intensive brute-force attacks on the problem/solution space and call it 'reasoning'

If they discover the cure to cancer, I don't care how they did it. "I don't trust anyone who claims they're superhumanly intelligent" doesn't follow from "all they do is <how they work>".

show 3 replies
Rover222today at 1:07 AM

Yeah and everything is just atoms. If you reduce anything enough it’s not real.

semiinfinitelytoday at 12:50 AM

calculator is superhumanly intelligent