logoalt Hacker News

palatayesterday at 11:58 PM1 replyview on HN

> It would take about 15 minutes to create a browser extension that could make a hash of all the files loaded, to compare with other users with the extension installed

You completely underestimate it. I am absolutely certain that you cannot create a browser extension that meaningfully solves this problem in 15 minutes.

> Web applications are sandboxed in the web browser. Very little issue with that

Except that when we are talking about end-to-end encryption, the sandbox has nothing to do with it. The sandbox defends against something else, not the server serving you an end-to-end encryption program abusing it.

> AWS has a web-based terminal for EC2 instances. It's not a problem, a lot of people use it.

I genuinely can't see if you just don't understand the point being discussed at all, or if you keep saying off-topic things as a way to divert the discussion.


Replies

leptonstoday at 4:23 AM

>You completely underestimate it. I am absolutely certain that you cannot create a browser extension that meaningfully solves this problem in 15 minutes.

You are absolutely wrong. I write browser extensions, I can spin up a new one in a minute, and the code to monitor and hash all resources loaded by a webpage is trivially easy to do. It would be simple to set up a server to allow comparing the hashes, in a POC. I'm not talking about making this a robust service that everyone can use, I'm only talking about how easy it is to do in a general way. It's far easier than you think it is.

>>>I wouldn't run a web-based terminal, for instance (do people actually do that?).

>> AWS has a web-based terminal for EC2 instances. It's not a problem, a lot of people use it.

>I genuinely can't see if you just don't understand the point being discussed at all, or if you keep saying off-topic things as a way to divert the discussion.

You're right, I certainly don't understand the nonsense you're trying to convey.

I'm also tired of this pointless internet interaction. Goodbye.