logoalt Hacker News

copxyesterday at 7:40 PM2 repliesview on HN

Interesting thought experiment.

I would say, if you put Claude in an android body with voice recognition and TTS, people in 1991 would think they are interacting with a sentinent machine from outer space.


Replies

redfloatplaneyesterday at 8:16 PM

Thanks, I find it very interesting as well. I think very many people would assume they must be interacting with another person, and I don't think there's really a way to _prove_ it's not that, just through conversation. But we do have a lot of mechanisms for understanding how others think through conversation only, and so I think the approach of having a clinical psychiatrist interact with the model make sense.

gritspantsyesterday at 11:20 PM

They would just assume they were being pranked. America's Funniest Home Videos style or Candid Camera.