logoalt Hacker News

computerextoday at 1:47 AM5 repliesview on HN

Wars are about objectives. The USA managed to accomplish none of its objectives. Iran forced USA to concede and call for ceasefire before US could achieve objectives. That’s the definition of defeat. Iran won by not losing and holding out.

Iran has more leverage at the end of this war than it did at the start. Iran has proven that it has the capability to catastrophically disrupt global economy.


Replies

shashtoday at 2:01 AM

That analysis requires discovering what the US’s objectives were. Not sure we can…

show 7 replies
blixtoday at 3:15 AM

What action can Iran take today that they couldn't take a year ago? No one who has been paying attention should be surprised that Iran can shut down the straight. It has been a known factor for decades.

They have less leverage. The have so much less that they are forced to openly use their last and most powerful card for their survival, when they never have had to before. That is a position of weakness, not strength.

show 2 replies
Tangurena2today at 2:42 PM

[dead]

smcnctoday at 2:02 AM

More leverage with less conventional firepower? Objectives of reducing conventional military threats and nuclear weapons seem less now, no?

show 2 replies