logoalt Hacker News

jerftoday at 4:10 PM0 repliesview on HN

One of the reasons I'm comfortable using them as coding agents is that I can and do review every line of code they generate, and those lines of code form a gate. No LLM-bullshit can get through that gate, except in the form of lines of code, that I can examine, and even if I do let some bullshit through accidentally, the bullshit is stateless and can be extracted later if necessary just like any other line of code. Or, to put it another way, the context window doesn't come with the code, forming this huge blob of context to be carried along... the code is just the code.

That exposes me to when the models are objectively wrong and helps keep me grounded with their utility in spaces I can check them less well. One of the most important things you can put in your prompt is a request for sources, followed by you actually checking them out.

And one of the things the coding agents teach me is that you need to keep the AIs on a tight leash. What is their equivalent in other domains of them "fixing" the test to pass instead of fixing the code to pass the test? In the programming space I can run "git diff *_test.go" to ensure they didn't hack the tests when I didn't expect it. It keeps me wondering what the equivalent of that is in my non-programming questions. I have unit testing suites to verify my LLM output against. What's the equivalent in other domains? Probably some other isolated domains here and there do have some equivalents. But in general there isn't one. Things like "completely forged graphs" are completely expected but it's hard to catch this when you lack the tools or the understanding to chase down "where did this graph actually come from?".

The success with programming can't be translated naively into domains that lack the tooling programmers built up over the years, and based on how many times the AIs bang into the guardrails the tools provide I would definitely suggest large amounts of skepticism in those domains that lack those guardrails.