alt Hacker News> And, when was the last time we stopped perfecting something we thought useful and valuable? When was the last time our attempts were so perfectly futile that we stopped them, invented stories about why it was impossible, and made it a social taboo to be met with derision, scorn and even ostracism? To my knowledge, in all of known human history, we have done that exactly once, and it was millennia ago.
I feel dense here, but I can't figure out what you're referring to. I asked ChatGPT (hah!) and it suggested the Tower of Babel, perpetual motion machines, or alchemy, but none of them really fit the bill.
The Tower of Babel seems like an OK fit, but that's rather more poetic than what this seems to be getting at.
"Millennia" is what's really throwing me. We (respectable society, as the post outlines) didn't stop attempting alchemy or perpetual motion machines "millennia" ago, but a few centuries at most.
All I can think of is immortality. The very first surviving long recorded tale in human history that I'm aware of is about how it's a futile quest (The Epic of Gilgamesh, IIRC ~5,000ish years old in its earliest extant fragments, a few hundred years newer in reasonably-complete form). The trouble with that is despite wide observations over literally millennia that this has never even come close to working and repeated supposition and suggestion that it's unwise to attempt, outright impossible, or somehow sacrilegious (the "taboo" thing, as mentioned), I'm not aware of any time in history that rich people haven't been actively trying for it (including today! That's what all the body-freezing business is about, it's modern mummification, the contracts are the formulaic prayers carved in the tomb walls) and usually they're not exactly "scorned" or "ostracized" for it.